Tamil Nadu Chief Minister Vijay has written to Prime Minister Narendra Modi over a single answer given in the Rajya Sabha. The Minister of State for Jal Shakti, Raj Bhushan Choudhary, told the House that the Supreme Court judgment of 16 February 2018 does not expressly require Karnataka to obtain the consent of lower riparian states before building a structure across the Cauvery. In a demi official letter sent on Tuesday, Vijay called the reply disappointing and asked that it be withdrawn.
Asking for a withdrawal rather than a correction looks like an overreaction until you follow how clearances on inter state rivers actually get granted. A written answer is not a ruling and binds nobody. But it is the Union government stating on the record how it reads the court, and that reading is what a file cites years later when an approval is being processed. Tamil Nadu is not arguing with a sentence. It is trying to stop the sentence becoming the settled reading it gets quoted back at.
The legal case in the letter rests on the difference between a judgment not saying something and a judgment permitting it. Vijay points to the Constitution Bench in State of Karnataka versus State of Andhra Pradesh, the Alamatti matter, where the court held that Karnataka could not build to the disputed height without the consent of the other riparian states and without the approval of the Centre. He also cites the Cauvery tribunal's handling of Kerala's Pambar hydro electric project, which involved a consumptive use of just 0.1 thousand million cubic feet and still drew a direction that Kerala and Tamil Nadu jointly agree the schedule of releases so downstream irrigation was not affected.
That second example carries the weight of the argument. If a tenth of a unit of consumption was enough to require a jointly agreed release schedule, the objection to Mekedatu is not really about how much water a reservoir would hold. It is about who controls the timing of what flows downstream. Vijay's letter leans on Clause XI of the award, which bars an upper riparian state from acting in ways that affect scheduled deliveries except by mutual agreement, Clause XVIII, which lets each state regulate water inside its territory only in a manner consistent with the tribunal's order, and Clause XX, which allows the award to be modified only by agreement among the party states.

