The Supreme Court has reserved judgment on Tamil Nadu's appeal seeking confirmation that the state may extend reservation benefits to people from backward classes, most backward classes, denotified communities and Scheduled Castes who convert to Islam. A bench headed by Justice Prashant Kumar Mishra heard the state on Friday and will pronounce its order later.
The dispute runs from a government order of 9 March 2024, under which Tamil Nadu, acting on its Backward Classes Commission, would issue backward classes Muslim community certificates to eligible people who had embraced Islam from those categories. The state's senior counsel, Mukul Rohatgi and Siddharth Luthra, described the purpose as ensuring that people from socially and educationally backward communities are not stripped of affirmative action benefits solely because they changed religion. The Madras High Court quashed that order as unconstitutional on 25 June, holding that a person who embraces Islam cannot claim the status of backward class Muslim.
The case arrived through an individual. A man from Thoothukudi district, born to Hindu parents, converted to Islam and changed his name, holding a 2015 certificate from the Sunnath Jamath at Kayathar recording the conversion. He applied for a community certificate as Muslim Lebbai, the tahsildar at Kayathar refused, and he went to court. The 2024 government order was notified while his case was running, and it worked in his favour until the High Court struck it down.
The legal question is narrower and more technical than the political noise around it, and it turns on whether two separate instruments are being confused. The first is the Constitution (Scheduled Castes) Order of 1950, whose Paragraph 3 states that a person professing a religion different from Hinduism, later amended to include Sikhism and Buddhism, shall not be deemed a member of a Scheduled Caste. That is an express religious exclusion written into the order itself. Justice Mishra observed from the bench that a 1951 Madras High Court decision, G. Michael versus S. Venkateswaran, concerning a Scheduled Caste member who converted to Christianity and sought to contest a reserved seat, upheld the validity of that paragraph and has held the fort for seventy five years.
The second instrument is the backward classes list, which a state draws up under Articles 15(4) and 16(4) on the basis of social and educational backwardness. Tamil Nadu's argument is that this list contains no religion based exclusion at all, that the 1951 judgment decided what Paragraph 3 of the Scheduled Castes Order means and nothing more, and that it therefore does not prevent a state from classifying someone who was socially and educationally backward before conversion as a backward class Muslim after it. On this reading the High Court applied the logic of one list to a notification issued under the other.

